Skip to main content

I have an offer for my car and I am looking for advice on the sale process. He is buying it as is and I have the title. Let’s just say it is considerably more than the $17.5 I paid for it almost 40 years ago.

What is the best/safest way to do a transaction? Wire transfer? I had a friend sell his maybe 15 years ago for $65k. The guy came to Florida with a trailer and a briefcase filled with cash. My friend said it was the only way he bought/sold cars.

I know the buyer so I am not worried about any kind of shady deals but what is the best way to do this?
Thanks

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Cash works, get a marker from a staples it will leave a different color mark if it is a bad bill. Lots of bills to mark.

Or you can go to you bank and have them run it thru the counter/ checker, but they might want to know where it is coming from.

Wire transfer works great.

Cashiers check only check to take, call their bank to verify just to be safe

I wold say cash, have your bank run it through the anti counterfeit machine and put it in a safe deposit box there.

Considering the possibility of a home invasion thing, keeping large amounts of cash in "the house" is not a great idea.

Lots of people/business deal in large amounts of cash much bigger than this. The bank will not be shocked at all.

They won't even ask you where it is from. Frankly, they don't care.

@panteradoug posted:

Considering the possibility of a home invasion thing, keeping large amounts of cash in "the house" is not a great idea.

And, a number of years ago a friend of mine sold a car and put the cash in a dresser drawer because he and his wife were going out that evening and he didn't have time to get to the bank before they closed.  When he got home he found his house had been broken into, ransacked, and the cash was gone!  It was an expensive lesson!

@panteradoug posted:

Lots of people/business deal in large amounts of cash much bigger than this. The bank will not be shocked at all.

They won't even ask you where it is from. Frankly, they don't care.

As for large cash transactions, your bank will report any cash deposits of $10,000 or more to the IRS so they can tax it as income, and they will want to know the source.

Stick with a cashier's check or wire transfer.

Last edited by garth66

The IRS considers cashier's checks the same as cash.  Your gain from the $17.5K purchase price is a capital gain.  My understanding is that wire transfers are not considered "cash" by the IRS.  I am in a similar situation and seeking guidance from my CPA.  

Unless you plan to hide the transaction by not reporting the receipt of cash and keep the proceeds under your mattress, you should have it wired to your brokerage account.  

Whether you elect to file with the IRS is your choice.

@garth66 posted:

As for large cash transactions, your bank will report any cash deposits of $10,000 or more to the IRS so they can tax it as income, and they will want to know the source.

Stick with a cashier's check or wire transfer.

Your bank is mandated to report ANY transaction over $10,000, whether deposit or withdrawal.

Last edited by joules

I don't think a wire transfer to your brokerage account will circumvent the > $10K required reporting, and I'm a CPA, too (and I did do some basic online research).  But even a CPA isn't the best person to ask, it's more of a banking question, but I think even a brokerage house is held to that same requirement with respect to transactions in the "cash" account there, which may very well also be managed in partnership with a traditional bank anyway.  Securities sales there are exempt from that rule probably because they all will get reported on their annual consolidated 1099.   All that said, yes there are lots of reasons deposit transactions > $10K are not taxable (inheritances, receipt of gifts, loan proceeds, life ins proceeds on death of insured, transfer to invest additional funds into your brokerage account, property settlement in divorce, closing proceeds from sale of principal residence usually, etc.).  So such reporting doesn't automatically raise any particular red flag with the IRS.  2 points:  (1) "Substantial understatement" and especially "fraud" penalties get severe and would be over and above late payment penalties and interest.  Either case at least doubles the statute of limitations (no statute ever runs on "fraud").   and (2) If you report a gain transaction, you would add your improvements costs over the years to your initial cost basis, which will decrease the realized gain, and being long-term capital gain for assets held > 1 year, taxed at favorable federal rates.  Most of us have spent "improvements" dollars over decades of ownership.  Ordinary repairs/maintenance don't qualify, but still.  Not telling anyone what to do here, just making you aware.  Individual audit rates are incredibly low, well under 2% generally and probably under 1% recently, though higher for high-income taxpayers, etc.

Last edited by buttondoor

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×